The Green Councillors on Fingal made observations on DAA’s planning application. The main themes are

• The application follows unauthorised development in removing contaminated soil and therefore has to include a retention application to be valid;
• The application is inconsistent with the 1.5° target in the Paris Agreement;
• Forecasts of passenger growth do not take account of climate action;
• Noise impacts, especially at night;
• Surface water at the airport should be managed to avoid downstream flooding;
• Cycling infrastructure should be designed to maximise the quality of access to and past the airport;
• Car parking at the airport should not be increased;
• Soil contamination has not been adequately addressed in the application;
• Night flights and their impact on human health, the subject of enforcement action and a separate planning application need to be addressed first.

Fingal County Council have sought further information on the application and DAA have 6 months to respond.

David Healy, Green Party Councillor for Howth/Malahide on Fingal County Council, has welcomed the recent decision of An Bord Pleanála on a planning appeal for the demolition and replacement of a habitable house in Howth. 

I have received a response from Iarnród Éireann to an Access to Information on the Environment (AIE) request. The request sought the following:

• Any analyses of potential operational patterns involving a shuttle service between Howth Junction and Howth, requiring passengers to change at Howth Junction to access Bayside, Sutton and Howth.
• Any analyses of the time delays or reduced capacity of the network at Howth Junction caused by the current arrangement where northbound trains to Howth cross the southbound track from Malahide.
• Any analyses of the time savings or increased capacity of the network should one or more Howthbound trains be replaced by a shuttle service.
• A copy of the terms of reference for “studies which will examine the doubling of track capacity between Dublin’s Connolly and Malahide train stations, where DART and intercity traffic currently share the same tracks”, for which funding was awarded on 22nd June.

I have made a planning appeal in relation to the application to demolish and replace the Deer Park Hotel. I agree with the appropriateness of the existing hotel use and with the renovation of the hotel. The appeal focuses on three issues:

• Sustainability assessment of demolition and reuse
• Access and permeability by foot
• Support for FIngal’s decision to refuse a large new access road

The Fingal Councillors have written to the Chief Executive asking her to apply for the lifting of the stay placed on the enforcement notices issued requiring Dublin Airport to comply with the conditions of its 2007 planning permission.

My submission to Iarnród Éireann’s consultation on Dart+ North

• welcomes the study just announced of the double-tracking of Malahide to Connolly;
• opposes the proposed infrastructure for a shuttle service to Howth and asks for the analysis of double tracking to happen first;
• welcomes the recognition that Howth Junction station is misdesigned but asks for a more fundamental redesign of the station; and
• asks for coordination between Iarnród Éireann and Fingal County Council who are working on a Sutton to Malahide greenway.

It follows my previous observations.

I have made an observation on the additional information received for application F22A/0372, subsequent to my previous observation. The main points are:

• The proposed new road should be refused.
• There should be an analysis of the sustainability of the proposal comparing demolition, reuse etc, as required by the new Fingal Development Plan.
• The application should provide for pedestrian links from the hotel to Howth and neighbouring residential areas.

My observations (click for details) on the proposed redesign of the pedestrianised New St. support the project and recommend:

• The Norway Maples on the street should be replaced over decades, not all at once.
• Street furniture on the street should be of a consistent high visual quality with an absolute ban on advertising.

The Green councillors on Fingal County Council have a made a submission to the consultation on Sustainable and Compact Settlements Guidelines run by the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage.

Our submission focusses on car parking issues, pointing to good policies adopted in the Fingal Development Plan 2023-2029.

Two aspects of the Fingal Plan are worth copying. First we advocate that minimum parking standards should be abolished from the planning system. The Fingal Plan does this for areas near public transport (which are effectively the entire developed area of Fingal.)

This is not abolishing parking entirely, it is that the planners will no longer require developers to provide more car parking than they want to, i.e. than they think the market is looking for. Our recommendations as regards car parking are informed by the work of planners like Donald Shoup and campaigns such as the Parking Reform Network. We are very conscious that minimum parking requirements have two significant negative effects. Minimum parking requirements reduce housing affordability, and it has been found again and again that removing the parking requirements enables the building of more housing. The cost minimum parking requirements imposes on housing becomes a subsidy which builds in an incentive to car use, contrary to our climate, health and quality of life goals for transport.

Secondly, we recommend that urban areas be designed primarily for walking, cycling and public transport, and that car parking be clustered rather than spread through out residential or mixed use areas as is often the case. We point to the provision of the Fingal plan providing for car-free neighbourhoods as a good example to be followed nationally. These recommendations are informed by positive experiences in pedestrianising existing areas and by the development of new car-free neighbourhoods in cities and towns across Europe and the world.

Following advice from the Planning Regulator, the Minister of State for Local Government and Planning has drafted a Direction to Fingal County Council to delete a provision about noise insulation included in the Plan. The Draft Direction is open to public consultation until Tuesday 2nd May 2023 at 11.59pm.

The 5 Green Councillors on Fingal County Council have made an observation pointing out that there is no legal basis for the draft direction and that the provisions were included to protect human health.

The objective, agreed by unanimous vote of the Council, specifies that insulation for homes affected by aircraft noise should achieve 40 dB Lnight, which is the standard recommended by the World Health Organisation to protect people from the impact on health caused by sleep disruption.

Anyone affected by aircraft noise should make their views known before the deadline.