Prosperity without Growth a report (and forthcoming book) by Tim Jackson from the UK Sustainable Development Commission is an excellent overview of what is going wrong and the direction we need to go in to reach sustainability.  It is a remarkably clear and straightforward synthesis, very readable but getting to the heart of the challenge we face. 

A chairde,

5 years ago I made a submission in relation to the overall sustainable development approach of the Development Plan and in particular the energy transition aspects of the Plan.  I attach a copy for information.

Unfortunately, it did not lead to a fundamental change in the plan itself.  However, the work of the Green Councillors in the intervening period did lead to a significant improvement in the handling of energy issues by the Council, in particular through the introduction of building energy standards in Local Area Plans.  A good start has been made in progress towards sustainability in other areas as well, including residential design and incorporating biodiversity into planning and other areas of Council activity.  

Nonetheless,  the work in all these areas is just a start. There is a long way to go and I urge the Council in preparing a draft plan to focus on the transition to sustainability.

The plan should not assume that a continuation of business as usual is possible. In fact, we are coming up against the limits to growth.   This is evident in many respects:

    * We are at the peak availability of the oil and gas supplies on which our lifestyles and the growth economy are predicated.(As predicted (Before the Wells Run Dry, 2003)  the resulting price spike has knocked the global economy into recession and prices have fallen again due to the recession. As demand recovers, prices will spike again.)
    * We have exceeded the ability of the atmosphere to absorb fossil fuel emissions and are massively disrupting the climate as a result.
    * We have exceeded the capacity of the biosphere and are causing massive biodiversity loss as a result.

Some links which will give ideas of the kinds of actions which could be integrated into the Strategy:

http://www.transitiontowns.org/

http://www.postcarbon.org/

http://www.iclei.org/index.php?id=800

http://www.lga.gov.uk/lga/publications/publication-display.do?id=22001

http://www.klimabuendnis.org/

http://www.naturvardsverket.se/upload/03_lagar_och_andra_styrmedel/ekonomiska_styrmedel/investeringsprogram/lip/local_climate_protection_measures_in_sweden.pdf

I suggest that the use of a methodology such as the ecological footprint (see www.envirocentre.co.uk, www.bestfootforward.co.uk)also be considered.

Regards,

David Healy

(Although I’m usually pretty strict about keeping this website on local issues, this article on the big picture was in my recent newsletter and people found it interesting. Thanks to Richard Douthwaite for much of the content.)

Almost every day, an economist, a banker or an organisation like the
IMF tells us that the US economy will start to pick up at the end of
the year. Most of them then add that it could be two years after that
before life gets back to normal in Ireland and the rest of the world.

They are wrong. The world will never be “normal” again. It will never
return to the high-growth path that gave birth to the Celtic Tiger.
Here’s why: •    Insufficient energy will be available to make global growth possible. The factor that sparked the credit crunch was the huge flow of purchasing power to energy- and commodity-producing countries. This was due to demand reaching the limit of supply because we are halfway through our geological endowment of oil.  The recession has reduced demand and oil prices have dropped. Growth takes a lot of energy. If it were to resume, demand would soon exceed supply, energy prices would soar and, once again,  knock the stuffing out of the global economy.
 
•    People are not going to invest in the conventional economy. Around 20% of the jobs in the average country are the direct result of people, firms and governments  investing in new houses, shopping centres, factories and infrastructure. These investments have stopped, causing massive unemployment, and will only resume when demand in the economy has returned to its 2008 peak and extra capacity is needed. But how can demand ever reach its previous level once investment has stopped?
 
Only the Greens know what to do about both problems. We see the crisis as the opportunity to build the stable, sustainable fairer world that we’ve been thinking about for a generation. 

The Green Party is working towards an Ireland in which:  
•    Income is distributed more fairly. The large gap between the earnings of those at top and those at the bottom will be drastically reduced. In a less frenetic, more stable economy,  over-incentivising risk-taking is the last thing you want to do.
 
•    Housing costs take a much smaller share of everyone’s income. This would be achieved by restricting the size of the mortgages the banks could give in relation to a borrower’s earnings.
 
•    Everyone shares in the benefits from the private use of our common resources through a citizen’s income. Most of this would come from a site value tax and from charging for greenhouse gas emissions.
 
•    All our energy comes from our own renewable resources. This would create skilled jobs, provide the basis for pensions and reduce our reliance on our ability to export to a highly-competitive and potentially unstable world market.
 
In government, the Greens have been able to make tremendous changes in the areas for which we have ministerial responsibility.  Environment Minister John Gormley has worked to ensure that the planning system supports the new low-energy economy and to put together a green new deal response to the economic crisis.  Energy minister Eamon Ryan has been laying the foundations for the new investments.  He’s already announced that the electricity grid is being strengthened to take more windpower and that three interconnectors are to be built to export surplus wind electricity to Britain.  ESB Networks has started installing “smart” meters so that people can do energy-intensive things, like switching on their immersion heaters or charging the batteries of their electric cars when the wind is blowing and power is cheap.   

This new type of investment will increase demand in the existing, conventional economy, boosting businesses and increasing the government’s tax-take.  And don’t forget that Ireland has some of the best renewable energy resources in Europe.

In the longer term, though, we’ll have to work longer to earn the energy, food and everything else we need because the huge subsidy we’ve been getting from using fossil energy will no longer be there. This will reverse the historical trend.  In the world that’s emerging, the higher-priced food will mean that farms can be smaller, less specialised and able to sell better food with less packaging locally again. 

Although bulk sea freight will stay pretty cheap, hauling goods around the world by truck and plane will become much more expensive.   As a result, you won’t be buying your kitchen via a catalogue from a firm in Italy but getting a local craft workshop to make it to your design.  Far fewer manufactured goods will come from abroad and strong, diverse local economies will emerge. These will be much more stable than the present system and provide a wider range of career options in each community. 

The challenge we face as a society is to manage this transition to a low-carbon economy.  We must ensure that it happens smoothly and quickly.  We can move to a stable long-term economy supporting a fairer society with better quality of life. This is the goal Greens are working towards at local, national and European level.  

Arising from a report to the Fingal Development Board at its meeting today, I have written to relevant Board members and staff asking them to get involved with the problem at Howth Junction.

From: David Healy / Daithí Ó hÉalaithe
Date: Wed, May 13, 2009 at 3:46 PM
Subject: disability/accessiblity and access between Howth Junction Railway Station and Fás and Baldoyle Industrial Estate
To: Margaret Richardson,  Ciaran Byrne, PJ Howell , Eithne Mallin

Dear Margaret, PJ, Eithne, and Ciarán,

I refer to Margaret’s report to todays FDB meeting.

I note the first paragraph in relation to the statutory obligations on public sector organisations and the second paragraph on the responsibility of the CBD under Local Government Circular LG02/07.

I would like to draw your attention to a longstanding problem with Iarnród Éireann’s blocking of access from Howth Junction to Baldoyle Industrial Estate including the Fás training centre.

The story to date is documented at the following links on my website.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

At the moment, a ruling from ABP and enforcement action from Dublin City Council are awaited.  I would hope FDB will engage with this problem created by a statutory body.

Regards,

David

In 2006, I brought forward a motion to have terms of reference for consultants brought to the Councillors before they were issued.  As frequently happens when Councillors seek to take a role in decision-making, the Manager went to Senior Counsel to get legal advice that this motion was illegal, legal advice which I think is completely ill-founded.  The matter was brought up at the Corporate Policy Group which in December 2006 decided as follows:

"It was AGREED to identify upcoming Contract and Briefs to Consultants and list them on Area Meeting Agenda."

So this month, I asked how many had been referred to the Area Cttees. The answer: None. >>>
FINGAL COUNTY COUNCIL MEETING

11th May 2009

ITEM No.5 
 
Question: Councillor D. Healy

“To
ask the Manager on how many instances have draft terms of reference for
consultants been brought before an Area Committee or a Strategic Policy
Committee of this Council since this matter was raised in October
2006?”

Reply:

There have been no instances of
draft terms of reference for consultants been brought before an Area
Committee or a Strategic Policy Committee of Fingal County Council
since October 2006.  However, it should be noted when Counsels advice
was sought in relation to the Strategic Environment Assessment on the
Greater Dublin Strategic Drainage Study Strategy, it was sent in the
name of the Mayor on behalf of the Councillors.

This arises from discussions around the appointment of consultants in general,
a function that is solely exercised by the Manager.  The Manager is
obliged to adhere to such guidelines as are issued by the Department of
Finance on procurement of consultants services.

Terms of
reference or briefs for appointment will follow the standards laid down
for the provision of such services which to the greater extent are
highly technical performance standards and ethical insofar as conflict
of interest etc will apply.
<<<

My my re-election leaflet as a candidate in the newly combined Howth Malahide ward is here.

My recent newsletter is here.