I’m putting links to radio and television interviews on this post.
Discussion on RTE’s Tonight with Vincent Browne in February 2006 in relation to the Strategic Infrastructure Bill.
Author Archives: david
Green Party Transport Policy launched
The Party’s Transport Policy was launched recently. It is a strong and comprehensive document. Some of the interesting points:
- The Baldoyle to Ballymun light rail/metro link is included (along with other light rail lines in Dublin Cork and Galway).
- Climate change is a core concern of the policy.
- There is a detailed cycling section which draws heavily from the work of the Dublin Cycling Campaign and
- The policy recognises the induced traffic phenomenon, which means that building roads to reduce congestion fails.
The policy is here (pdf format)
Erosion and Flooding Risks on Burrow Beach
The Environment Department of the Council has commissioned a study into Burrow Beach because of recent erosion of the dunes and the beach. (http://www.fingalcoco.ie/minutes/meeting_doc.aspx?id=4256) The Water Services Department of the Council has been involved in a major study of flooding risks in Dublin. Erosion is addressed in this only insofar as it affects flooding risks. There will be a report on this study to the full Council on 12th February.
FINGAL COUNTY COUNCIL
MALAHIDE/HOWTH AREA COMMITTEE
[Services A – Transportation, Environment and Water Services]
Thursday, 1st February, 2007
ITEM NO. 33
WATER SERVICES MOTIONS
PROGRESS IN EXAMINING COASTAL EROSION IN BURROW
BEACH AREA/STUDY OF EROSION AND FLOODING RISKS
"That the Manager report on progress in examining coastal erosion in the
Burrow Beach area and that the Committee recommends that the Council
organise for the carrying out of a study of erosion and flooding risks in this
area."
Report:
The dune system at Burrow Road Sutton has been under severe pressure
in the last year or so resulting in a significant reduction at the location with
the consequent threat of flooding to properties on Burrow Road. Environment
Department staff met on site with a representative of Royal Haskoning, a
consultancy that has carried out a number of maritime related projects for the
Council. Following the meeting the company was asked to submit a proposal
to carry out a "Historical Evolution Study" in an attempt to develop a picture
of the evolution of the coastline to aid in the understanding of the natural
processes at work and also to develop a number of short term options which
might help to arrest the erosion. It is likely that some short term measures may
be possible, subject to monies being available.
As part of the preparation of the study it was decided that the most efficient
means of gathering local knowledge of the evolution of the area would be to
gather interested locals for a meeting with the maritime consultants. This
meeting took place in the Marine Hotel, Sutton on Tuesday 16th. January to
collate any data held by people living along the beach e.g. photographs, family
personal histories etc.
It should be noted that any significant long term protection measures at this
location are likely to be a significant cost item and would require funding from
the Department of Communications, Marine and Natural Resources under the
National Programme for Coastal Projects.
In relation to the second part of the motion the following is the position.
Haskoning were appointed in April 2003 by Dublin City Council as Service
Providers on the Dublin Coastal Flooding Protection Project. This project was
implemented in direct response to the extreme flooding tide and flood event
that was experienced across Dublin and Fingal on 1st February, 2002. The
project encompassed the coastline in the Dublin City Area and northwards
from the city boundary along the coastline as far as the Martello Tower north
of Portmamock. In addition, the asset survey for the project was extended to
cover the entire Fingal coastline.
The study is now complete and a Draft Final Report was produced and has yet
to be finalised. The Report outlines a series of strategies and policies to
manage the risk of future flooding and also identifies a number of short term
and long term flood relief works which will further reduce the risk of flooding.
A presentation will be made to the Council at the meeting on 12th February,
outlining the progress of the study to date.
Burrow Road Beach was included in the Study and the attached plan
designates the various stretches of beach in terms of risk to flooding eg.
Stretch of Beach Risk Description Action Required Priority
C4 >1:200 Rock Wall
C3 1:10 to 1:50 Eroding Dunes
with retired defences
C2 1:10 to 1:50 Dunes with shingle face
Cl 1:50 to 1:200 Low dunes with
retired sea defence
walls
B14 >1:200 Eroding clay cliff
B5 >1:200 Embankment Investigate Medium
repairs to
gabions
B1 1:10 to 1:50
Some works are required to be carried out in the medium term. All works
identified in the study will be carried out subject to funding being available.
The Study did not address Coastal Erosion other than where it resulted in
increased flood risk.
Coastal walkway/cycleway design expected this autumn
The coastal walkway/cycleway between Baldoyle and Portmarnock which local people have been campaigning for for decades finally seems to be on the way.
Motion 28 at yesterday’s meeting:
Councillor D. Healy
"That the Manager report on progress in relation to the coastal walk/cycleway between Baldoyle and Portmarnock."
The report indicated that the study on the Moyne Road was expected by early summer and the coastal route by the end of the year or before.
Some small progress on the Baldoyle-Ballymun light rail
At yesterday’s Area Cttee, I raised the issue of progress in the light rail element of the multimodal study which the Council directed in September 2007 be carried out for the North Fringe/South Fringe Area.
My motion: "That the Manager report on progress in relation to the light rail
elements of the transport study for the North Fringe/South Fringe Area."
The officials reported back that they have been in discussions with Dublin City Council and the Railway Procurement Agency, both of which have been positive and cooperative. They are meeting soon to decide how to fund the study and how to approach the selection of consultants. Fingal’s officials will come back with a further report as soon as meeting has been held.
Meanwhile there will be some sort of report to the Area Cttee. meeting on 15th in relation to Roads in the area. I hope there will not be an attempt to go ahead with road planning in the absence of public transport planning!
Result of meeting with Dublin Bus and Iarnród Éireann
As I mentioned before, Iarnród Éireann and Dublin Bus came into our Area Cttee. today. We got some interesting information, but there was definitely no breakthrough on any major issue.
Iarnród Éireann
- 1. Lack of regular, clock-face Dart Services to Bayside/Sutton/Howth
- 2. Very low Dart frequency in the evenings especially Sunday evenings
No progress on either of these. The issue is as set out here.
The only explanation I can come up with is that IE have decided to save
a few euros by having one fewer driver on the evening shift. The
result from the point of view of a resident of Bayside, Baldoyle,
Sutton or Howth is that planning to get a Dart from town in the evening
is a much less attractive option than it was 20 years ago, with waits
of 40 minutes on weekdays and 1 hour on a Sunday.
- 3. Integrated ticketing between Dart and Bus
Nothing.
Talk about new systems. No explanation as to why the existing system
which both DB and IE use at the moment is not used to provide
integrated tickets.
- 4. Blocking of disabled access to Howth Junction Station
Astonishingly IE appeared not to know what I was talking about. Fortunately, Dublin City Council understands the issue and has put in planning conditions to address it, and Fingal County Council is taking enforcement action as although most of the station is in Fingal’s area, no planning permission has been sought for it.
- 5. Development potential at Howth Junction Station
- 6. Underpass at Bayside Station
- 7. Layout of car parking and access to beach at Howth Station
- 8. Parking enforcement at bus stop on Howth Station forecourt
- 9. Online timetable failing to show connections which can be made at Howth Junction.
Dublin Bus
- 1. 31C service waiting on the road outside Howth Dart Station
blocking views of the pedestrian traffic lights and of crossing
pedestrians
Issue not resolved. This significant traffic hazard remains.
- 2. Routing of buses on Howth Peninsula – potential to extend
the 17A to travel along Kilbarrack Road through Sutton Cross, over
Howth Summit to Howth Dart Station.(with extra buses on the route of
course) instead of the 31B.
Because only Clontarf Garage (31s) and not Harristown (17A) was represented at the meeting we couldn’t get any update on this.
There are some planned changes to the buses in the area. All are
awaiting approval from the Department of Transport, many for long
periods of time. There is no formal input from Councillors.
The 29A will extend along Grange Rd to a new terminus in Abbey Park.
When this happens, the 32B will no longer go into Abbey Park, but
travel straight through to Portmarnock.
There will be a new route 128 from the area of the new train station
(near Fr. Collins’ Park) to Donaghmede Roundabout, Clare Hall and down
Malahide Rd to Rathmines, 14/15 buses – 10 minutes all day.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Report released on 2nd February
The Summary for Policymakers of the report, “Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis”, the first volume of “Climate Change 2007”, will be released on 2nd February. The press conference will be broadcast live on the web.
Extracts from the press release:
"The report assesses the current scientific knowledge of the natural and human
drivers of climate change, observed changes in climate, the ability of
science to attribute changes to different causes, and projections for
future climate change.
"The Report includes significantly advanced observations of the climate
system, presents new projections of future global climate change using
results from 19 climate models, all with improved representations of
physics, chemistry, and spatial resolution. The report also covers the
range of anthropogenic greenhouse gases and other factors that drive
climate change. There will also be a Chapter assessing the
paleoclimatic perspective.
"The WGI report does not cover the impacts of climate change or options
for the mitigation of climate change. These aspects will be covered in
subsequent reports by Working Group II (impacts, adaptation and
vulnerability), and Working Group III (mitigation options) to be
finalised respectively in early April and early May this year In
addition a Synthesis Report covering key findings of all three Working
Groups will be released in late 2007."
The press conference will be broadcast here.
New sewage pipe to end discharge of raw sewage at Nose of Howth
Construction work is starting for the new sewer which will take sewage
from Howth and Sutton to Sutton pumping station. When finished this
will end the discharge of raw sewage from the nose of Howth.
There will be inevitable disruption during construction, but no work will be allowed on Harbour Road during the summer.
Details of the work are available here, including a large pdf map which explains the project.
Some further relevant details are as follows:
- There will be no work east of Howth Dart Station between 1st May and 31st September.
- Working hours are 7am to 7pm Monday to Friday.
- The road will be reinstated every evening and at weekends.
Issues to be raised with Iarnród Éireann and Dublin Bus
Iarnród Éireann and Dublin Bus are coming to our Area Committee today.
I will be raising the following issues. Unfortunately, unlike most
European countries, control of public transport is completely centralised in Ireland. Local authorities have no power over public
transport, so our influence is limited. I have submitted the following issues to be responded to.
Iarnród Éireann
- Lack of regular, clock-face Dart Services to Bayside/Sutton/Howth
- Very low Dart frequency in the evenings especially Sunday evenings
- Integrated ticketing between Dart and Bus
- Blocking of disabled access to Howth Junction Station
- Development potential at Howth Junction Station
- Underpass at Bayside Station
- Layout of car parking and access to beach at Howth Station
- Parking enforcement at bus stop on Howth Station forecourt
- Online timetable failing to show connections which can be made at Howth Junction.
Dublin Bus
- 31C service waiting on the road outside Howth Dart Station blocking views of the pedestrian traffic lights and of crossing pedestrians
- Routing of buses on Howth Peninsula – potential to extend the 17A to travel along Kilbarrack Road through Sutton Cross, over Howth Summit to Howth Dart Station.(with extra buses on the route of course) instead of the 31B.
New Dart Timetable has fewer trains than 23 years ago
One-hour gaps between Dart trains to Bayside, Sutton and Howth.
In 1984 there were 6 morning peak-hour departures from Howth (at 0800, 0810, 0825, 0836, 0850 and 0900), compared to 3 trains (0759, 0820 and 0845) over the same period today. Malahide has 2 Darts and 1 railcar in the same hour, so there is a net reduction in the total number of Dart trains leaving. There may be a justification that there is a signalling capacity constraint during peak times.
There is no such justification for the lack of evening services:
Sunday evening from City Centre to Howth in 1984 – 10 trains: 2034, 2054, 2119, 2134, 2154, 2214, 2234, 2254, 2314, 2334
Sunday evening from City Centre to Howth in 2007 – 5 trains: 2027, 2110, 2210, 2310, 2350
Maybe the 5 missing Darts are going to Malahide? No, there are only 3 departures to Malahide over this time period: 2040, 2140 and 2240.
This reduction in services was introduced in 2006 and has been repeated in the 2007 timetable despite strong protests from passengers.
The Greens believe public transport must be maintained as a convenient frequent service throughout the day and in the evenings. This decline in the Dart service must be reversed. Trains, trams and buses must be integrated into a single efficient and convenient network. Public transport is a top priority for Greens in Dublin.
